Kids in the Kitchen: Steak with Parsley Garlic Herb Butter


This week, it was Brandan’s turn to cook dinner. The excitement building, Brandan has changed his mind a few times over the past few weeks on what to prepare. Lasagna? Steak? Lobster? Steak AND lobster? (Okay, so I vetoed the lobster. Gotta keep these “Kids in the Kitchen” things under budget!) After deliberation, (and explaining why we couldn’t do lobster) we finally agreed on a simple, but satisfying meal of grilled steak, baked potatoes, and green beans.

Honestly, I don’t usually prepare a lot of steak for the kids. Two of them are not big steak fans, so we end up having leftovers. (To me, leftover steak just is never as good as it was the first time.) Besides, good steak is usually pretty pricey. However, I was lucky to find some decent T-bone steaks on sale. Brandan, needless to say, was excited. So was I. After a late-night soccer game, (I play amateur indoor soccer, and this Friday night our game was at 12:30 am. Yes, 12: 30 AM. Guess that’s technically no longer Friday night.) and working for a few hours Saturday, I was tired. This meal was simple. So simple, in fact, it hardly needs a recipe. Good choice, Brandan!

Lately, I have been making a lot of herb butter. My most common creation involves parsley, not only because it is versatile, but also because my garden is overrun by it at the moment. Butter, parsley, garlic, salt and pepper – it’s as straighforward as that. The best part of taking a few moments to create an herb butter? It adds another dimension of flavor to your dish, without over-complicating it. Whether it tops your steak, your baked potato, (Brandan and I chose to use it for both!) or anything else, it imparts a fresh “summery” taste that’s sure to please.

To prepare our steak dinner, we simply baked the potatoes. Rubbed a little olive oil and salt on the skin first – makes it nice and crispy. (Brandan loved getting his hands oily!) Next, we went out to the garden to gather a little parsley for our herb butter (recipe below). Once that was in the refrigerator, it was time for the steaks.

It has taken me a while to properly grill a steak. (Yes, I’ve charred a few steaks in my day!) Now, I can generally grill a steak without much stress or worry, and that’s even on an aging gas grill with its fair share of hot spots. Of course, every grill cook has their methods – here is what I stick to:

Bring steak to room temperature before grilling. (This allows you to more accurately feel how “done” the steak is without a thermometer – see below.) Season with your favorite rub or seasoning blend. (I prefer seasoning with salt, pepper, and smoked paprika.)


Heat the grill to high heat. Add steaks, and grill for about 3 minutes, and flip. Turn heat down to medium or medium-low (if steak is really thick) and cook for 3-4 minutes, or until steak is cooked to the temperature you desire. Rather than cutting into the steak, or poking it multiple times with a meat thermometer, I have an alternate method of testing the “doneness” of my steaks, courtesy of Gordon Ramsay. With your index finger, press your cheek lightly. That’s what rare feels like, if you were to press the steak. Press your chin lightly for medium, and your forehead for well done. Once your steaks are done, remove from grill.

Slice the herb butter into rounds, and add a pat or two of herb butter to the top of each steak. Tent with foil, and allow to rest for 5-10 minutes, allowing the juices to return to the center of the steak.

Brandan’s favorite part to eat, undoubtedly, was the steak. He finished off his steak, plus a bit of his brother’s.

Herb Butter:

1 stick unsalted butter, softened

1/4 c flat-leaf parsley, chopped

1 small clove garlic, minced

Pinch of salt and crushed black pepper

 Mix butter, garlic, and parsley together until well blended. Add salt and pepper and mix. Using plastic wrap, roll herb butter into a log (about 1 1/2 inches in diameter) and refrigerate until firm.

Brandan chopping parsley for the herb butter

Brandan chopping parsley for the herb butter


Filed under Beef, Gluten-Free, Main Dishes

21 responses to “Kids in the Kitchen: Steak with Parsley Garlic Herb Butter

  1. Wow – I think even I could pull that off! Thanks for a great summer dinner idea! I love the herb butter recipe, too – I’ve seen people make that up as gifts for the holidays, depending on the herb mixture… yum!

  2. Nicely done of the steak. I think Brandan made a good choice. Though you can tell that he’s the adventurous type when he mentions lobster. =)

  3. tastyeatsathome

    Bread + Butter – Thank you! Calling Brandan adventerous is almost an understatement! He’s a boy after my own heart in the food arena, he’ll try just about anything once, and he likes a lot of different foods. The other two? I just hope they outgrow their picky tendencies!

  4. tastyeatsathome

    Cindy – thanks! The herb butter is even yummier on a Rehoboth Ranch bone-in ribeye. That’s a steak that’ll make you swoon! (for those unfamiliar with Rehoboth Ranch, it is a nearby ranch that raises cattle, pigs, chickens, lamb, and turkeys naturally. Grass-fed beef that you can’t beat!)

  5. The only way we enjoy leftover steak is to coat a fry pan with a little butter and turn the heat on med-high for just a few minutes. Heating it a fry pan seems to help the steak retain its original flavor. Very difficult to do if your steak is thin and/or cooked more than “Medium” the first time around.

    Otherwise, I leftover steak in stroganoff or steak salad. A cold steak sandwich works pretty good for me, too! I was born and raised in Hereford, TX. We weren’t shy about our beef consumption. LOL

  6. That herb butter looks killer. Great picture of the steak!

  7. Brandon is a good guy for picking steaks! that steak looks really good too, cooked to perfection along with that yummy herb butter too

  8. tastyeatsathome

    Suz, thanks for the ideas! I think many of us native Texans are big beef eaters! I find steak salad works pretty well, then I’m keeping it cold. My husband loves to eat the leftovers alongside eggs in the morning, if we happen to have leftovers on a weekend!

  9. The steak sounds excellent with herb butter! My daughter is just beginning to enjoy steak.

  10. That looks lovely!

  11. Well done, Brandan! This looks delicious.

  12. I love having my kids in the kitchen with me. Thanks for the post. The steak looks amazing!!

  13. Looks delicious! Grumpy would LOVE this.

  14. 1) totally cool to have the kids in the kitchen!

    2) I LOVE the doneness test, what a great idea 😉

  15. KrisKishere

    Props to you for getting kids in the kitchen! The steak looks fabulous!

  16. Steak with butter, all warm and melty. MMMMMMM!!!!!

  17. It’s great to see little sweet and serious chefs on Kitchen!
    I love your herb butter idea.Delicious combination.

  18. Great steak delicious looking ..well done xx

  19. Pingback: Slow-Cooker Pot Roast « Tasty Eats At Home

  20. Sanin M

    This is so cute. Great article. I must say I’m a steak LOVER. You might wanna check out Allen Brothers, Chicago Steaks Co, or MeatHub ( All three rock, best steaks online.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s